Pricing

How to set your first handyman rate

What should I charge as a new handyman?

Do not start from what you earned per hour as an employee. Add the income you need for a year, your real annual overhead, your tax burden, and a little retained profit, then divide by the hours you can genuinely bill rather than the hours you will work. That number is your floor. Check it against local demand and adjust the offer, never the arithmetic.

Why the obvious method gives the wrong answer

Nearly everyone sets their first rate the same way. You think about what you were paid hourly as an employee, add something because now it is your business, and land on a number that feels like a lot to say out loud. Then you round it down a little, because saying it out loud is uncomfortable.

The reason that method fails is that an employee's hourly wage is already the number left over after somebody else absorbed a long list of costs. Your old employer paid the payroll taxes, the liability insurance, the vehicle, the fuel, the tools, the phone, the software, the accountant, the holidays, the sick days, and the weeks when the work was slow. When you go out on your own, every one of those moves onto your side of the ledger and none of them send you a notification.

The second failure is subtler. You are not paid for most of the hours you work. Driving between jobs, running for parts, writing estimates, chasing invoices, answering the phone in the middle of someone else's kitchen, and doing the books on Sunday night are all real work, and none of them appear on an invoice. An owner who works fifty hours and bills twenty-five is earning half of what they think their rate is.

Put those together and you get the most common story in the trade: fully booked, permanently tired, and somehow no better off than when you were on payroll.

Build the number from the bottom instead

The fix is arithmetic, and it takes about twenty minutes with a notepad.

Start with the income you actually need for a year. Not the number you would enjoy, the number that covers housing, food, transport, insurance, debt, savings, and the things that make working this hard worth it. Write it out line by line, because an estimate here quietly becomes an estimate everywhere downstream.

Add your business overhead for a full year. Insurance premiums, the vehicle payment or its depreciation, fuel, maintenance and tires, phone, software, licensing and renewals, tool replacement, consumables, marketing, accounting, and bank and processing fees. Do this annually rather than monthly, because the annual items are exactly the ones a monthly budget forgets.

Add your tax burden. You owe self-employment tax on top of income tax and nobody is withholding it for you. Get the percentage from an accountant based on your own situation, then treat it as a line in the calculation rather than an unpleasant surprise in April.

Add a little retained profit. A business that only ever covers its owner's pay has nothing to reinvest and nothing to absorb a bad quarter. Zero here is a choice, and it is a fragile one.

Now the divisor, which is where everyone goes wrong. Take fifty-two weeks, subtract the weeks you genuinely will not work, then multiply the remainder by the hours you will be on a customer's job. Not hours worked. Hours billed. For most solo operators the honest figure is far lower than they expect.

Divide the total by the billable hours and you have your floor.

A worked example, clearly labeled as arithmetic

The numbers below are illustrative. They are not market data, not a survey, and not a suggestion about what you should charge. They exist to show the shape of the calculation.

Say you need seventy thousand dollars of income, your annual overhead totals twenty-two thousand, your tax burden works out to twenty-four thousand, and you want the business to retain eight thousand. That is one hundred and twenty-four thousand dollars of revenue required.

Now the hours. Forty-six working weeks after vacation, holidays, illness, and the seasonal lull. Twenty-two billable hours in each of those weeks, which sounds low until you track it and discover it is generous. That is one thousand and twelve billable hours.

One hundred and twenty-four thousand divided by one thousand and twelve is roughly one hundred and twenty-three dollars an hour. Substitute your own figures and the number will be different; the structure will not.

Notice what happens if you improve the divisor. Getting from twenty-two to twenty-eight billable hours a week, purely through tighter routing and a better stocked van, drops the required rate by about a fifth without changing a single cost. That is why scheduling and van organization are pricing decisions, not just operational ones.

Sanity checking the number against your market

The floor is what you need. What the market will pay is a separate question, and the two are reconciled by changing the offer rather than the arithmetic.

  • Look at who is actually charging more than you. In every market there are operators charging well above the average and staying busy. Find out what they do differently: responsiveness, presentation, warranty, scheduling reliability, or a niche. It is rarely the tool bag.
  • Change the customer, not the price. If your floor is above what your current customer type will pay, the answer is usually a different customer: property managers, realtors, repeat commercial accounts, or homeowners in a different part of your area.
  • Change the job mix. Some job types carry your rate comfortably and some fight it constantly. Track which is which for two months and let the data reshape what you advertise.
  • Add a minimum before you add a discount. A minimum that covers the drive and the setup fixes more of the profitability problem than a rate change does, because the short distant job is where the money actually leaks.
  • Test with new inquiries only. Set the new number for everyone who calls starting on a specific date and leave existing customers alone. Within a month you will have real evidence instead of a theory.

If the market genuinely cannot support your floor after all of that, the honest conclusion is that this service area and this job mix cannot support this business, and the fix is upstream of pricing.

The two habits that protect the number

Once you have a rate, two habits keep it real.

The first is tracking your actual billable ratio. Two weeks of notes on your phone (hours on site versus hours worked) will tell you more about your business than any advice will. Whatever the number turns out to be, it is the number your rate has to be built on, and it will change as your routing and stocking improve.

The second is logging real job durations. After twenty door adjustments or twenty faucet swaps you will know your genuine average, and that is when you can move that job to a flat rate. Flat rates are how getting faster starts increasing your margin instead of shrinking your invoice, and they are the single biggest lever available to a competent operator.

Neither habit is exciting. Both take about a minute a day. Together they are the difference between a rate you guessed and a rate you can defend.

Questions

Frequently asked questions

Is it bad to start cheap to get reviews?
Starting slightly below your eventual rate for a short, defined period is a legitimate tactic, as long as it has an end date and the customers know the rate is introductory. What hurts is drifting into a low rate permanently, because raising prices on an established customer base is far harder than starting at a defensible number.
Should I tell customers my hourly rate up front?
Yes, along with your minimum. Publishing both filters out the people who were never going to pay properly and saves you the unbilled hour of discovering that in person. The customers who stay have already accepted the number before you drive anywhere.
How do I know if my rate is too low?
The clearest signal is that you are consistently booked further out than customers want to wait, across seasons rather than during one good month. The second is that nobody ever hesitates at your number. Some price resistance is healthy; none at all usually means you are the cheap option.

About the author

Brandon Rodriguez, Founder, ColabContent LLC

Brandon Rodriguez is the founder of ColabContent LLC and works on marketing for trades businesses. He writes Handyman Business to put the parts owners actually get stuck on (pricing that covers overhead, licensing that varies by state, and marketing that compounds) in one place, in plain language. This is general business information, not legal, tax, or insurance advice; confirm licensing and coverage requirements with your state board and your own insurer.

Handyman Business is reader-supported. Some links on this site are Amazon affiliate links, which means we may earn a commission when you buy through them, at no extra cost to you. We only point at categories of gear a working handyman actually needs, and we never take payment to recommend a specific brand.