The one setup cost that is genuinely not optional
Plenty of things people tell you to buy before your first job can honestly wait. Insurance is not one of them, and the reason is arithmetic rather than caution.
The work happens inside other people's homes, near their water supply, their electrical system, and their possessions. A single bad afternoon (a nicked supply line above a finished ceiling, a dropped tool on a stone counter, a customer tripping over your cord) can cost more than a year of profit. Without coverage, that number comes out of your own assets.
There is also a commercial reason. Property managers, realtors, general contractors, and most commercial clients will ask for a certificate of insurance before they let you on site, and those are the steadiest and best-paying relationships in this trade. Homeowners increasingly ask too.
What follows is what each coverage actually does, in plain language, so the conversation with an agent is one you can steer.
What each coverage actually does
- General liability. Covers bodily injury and property damage you cause to other people or their property. The cracked tile, the nicked pipe, the visitor who trips over your extension cord. This is the base policy, the one that produces the certificate everyone asks for, and the one standing between an accident and your personal assets.
- Tools and equipment coverage. General liability does not replace your own stolen or damaged tools. That is a separate coverage, often called inland marine or a tools and equipment endorsement, and it is usually inexpensive. Photograph and list your tools with serial numbers now, because you will not remember the inventory after a break-in.
- Commercial auto. A personal auto policy can deny a claim on a vehicle used primarily for business. If you drive to jobs carrying tools and materials, talk to your agent about a commercial policy or a business-use endorsement. Finding out during a claim is the expensive way to learn this.
- Workers compensation. Applies the moment anyone else works for you, with rules and thresholds that vary by state. Misclassifying a helper as a subcontractor to avoid it is one of the most expensive mistakes available in this trade, and it is one regulators actively look for in construction.
- Professional liability. Covers claims arising from advice or professional judgment rather than physical damage. Less commonly needed for pure repair work, more relevant if you consult, design, or advise on scope.
- An umbrella policy. Sits above your other policies and extends the limits. Worth asking about once you are working on higher-value properties or for commercial clients whose contracts require limits above your base policy.
A bond is not insurance
This is the single most misunderstood item in the whole conversation, and getting it wrong leaves people feeling protected when they are not.
A surety bond is a financial guarantee to the public, usually required by a licensing authority. If someone makes a valid claim against your bond and the surety pays it, the surety company then comes after you for that money. It protects your customer. It does not protect you, and it does not reduce your liability by a dollar.
So when a state or a city requires a bond, satisfy the requirement and then buy insurance separately. "Licensed and bonded" in an advertisement tells a customer you met a licensing requirement. "Insured" is the word that means something is standing behind an accident.
Questions to ask your agent
Use an independent agent who writes policies for contractors rather than the first online form you find. Then ask these specifically, because the answers vary by carrier and the exclusions are where the surprises live.
- What height limit applies to my work?. Gutter cleaning and second-story work are common handyman requests and a common exclusion. Ask for the specific height, in writing.
- Am I covered for water damage from a failed connection?. Fixture and supply line work is quick, well-paid, and has an expensive failure mode. Ask exactly how a claim from a failed connection would be treated.
- What happens if I do work I am not licensed for?. Many policies will not respond to a claim arising from work you were not licensed to perform. This is the quiet risk that turns a covered accident into a personal liability.
- Are mold and lead excluded?. Usually yes, and often broadly. If your work touches pre-1978 housing, understand both the federal renovation rules and how your policy treats it.
- Does the policy cover my work after I leave?. Ask about completed operations coverage, which is what responds when a problem shows up weeks after the job rather than while you are standing there.
- How fast can I get a certificate of insurance?. Practical rather than technical, but it matters. Commercial clients ask for a certificate before scheduling, and a slow agent costs you jobs.
Read your own exclusions once, out loud
Almost nobody does this and it takes twenty minutes. Find the exclusions section of your policy and read it against your actual list of services.
If something you regularly do appears in the exclusions, you have two honest options: add an endorsement that covers it, or stop doing it. What you cannot do is carry on while assuming it will be fine, because the whole point of the policy is the day it is not.
Then do the same with your customer-facing promises. If you advertise a service your policy excludes, you are advertising a risk you have chosen to carry personally.
Costs vary enormously by state, by scope of work, by payroll, and by claims history, so treat any national premium figure you read as noise. Get two or three real quotes from agents who write for contractors and compare the exclusions, not just the price.